NFL Rookie of the Year Odds - Stroud, Carter early favorites

NFL Rookie of the Year odds are forecasts about which NFL rookies might win the Offensive or Defensive Rookie of the Year awards.

The odds for NFL Rookie of the Year are typically more favorable early in the season, especially the pre-season. Lines become tighter as the season progresses. It’s one of the many risks vs. reward scenarios in sports betting.

The best NFL betting sites accept bets on Rookie of the Year odds almost all year, and you can make them easily with a free account. See below for how to get one.

Current NFL ROTY odds 

Our NFL Rookie of the Year odds feed has the latest lines from the best sports betting sites. Click on any odds to register for an account and claim your new customer sign-up bonuses 

Offensive Rookie of the Year odds

Who are the Offensive Rookie of the Year odds favorites?

C.J. Stroud, the second overall pick in the latest NFL Draft, has been making waves as the starting quarterback for the Houston Texans. Despite being a rookie, his impressive performance has been pivotal in leading the Texans to a commendable 3-3 start.

Through the first six games of the season, he has racked up 1,660 passing yards, thrown nine touchdowns, and has been intercepted only once. Stroud set a new record for pass attempts without an interception at the beginning of a career with 186 attempts in just five games, surpassing the previous record of 176 held by Dak Prescott of the Dallas Cowboys. 

Puka Nacua, once an under-the-radar fifth-round pick by the Los Angeles Rams, has quickly emerged as a breakout star in the NFL. Despite being drafted out of BYU in a later round, Nacua has left an undeniable mark early in his career, with 50 receptions on 70 targets, accumulating 598 yards and two touchdowns.

It's notable that he's set an NFL record for the most receptions in a single game by a rookie wide receiver, catching the ball 15 times. 

Bijan Robinson, the Atlanta Falcons' running back, has quickly become an integral part of their offense as the team stands at a 3-3 record. With 106 touches yielding 590 combined yards and two touchdowns in just six games,

Robinson has showcased his ability to deliver consistently. Although the debate continues regarding the merit of drafting running backs in the first round, the Falcons' decision to pick Robinson at No. 8 is certainly paying off.

Defensive Rookie of the Year odds

Who are the Defensive Rookie of the Year odds favorites?

Jalen Carter, selected ninth overall in the draft by the Philadelphia Eagles, has swiftly cemented his reputation as a force to be reckoned with on defense. In just a short time, he has tallied 3.5 sacks, seven solo tackles, and forced two fumbles. Fitting seamlessly into Philly's defensive framework, which is touted as one of the best in 2023, Carter has made significant waves in his first five games. 

Seattle Seahawks' cornerback, Devon Witherspoon, chosen fifth overall in the draft, has already made his mark with 20 solo tackles and an interception. He made a notable impact during the Seahawks' Week 4 victory against the New York Giants, where he not only sacked Giants' quarterback Daniel Jones twice but also managed to intercept him. This outstanding performance earned him the title of NFC Defensive Player of the Week. 

Will Anderson Jr., a dynamic defensive end chosen third overall by the Houston Texans, has achieved 17 solo tackles and a sack through the first six games of the season. Representing a rejuvenated Texans defense that had previously shown vulnerabilities, Anderson is ushering in a new era of resilience for the team.

Best sportsbooks for NFL ROTY odds

Nearly every sportsbook in the US posts futures odds for NFL Rookie of the Year. Below, see our favorite sportsbooks to place your bets on the NFL ROTY Award. 

• DraftKings Sportsbook: DraftKings offers various futures bets, including the NFL Rookie of the Year. It has an easy-to-use app and website; plus, it offers solid NFL welcome bonuses & promotions for new bettors. 
• FanDuel Sportsbook: FanDuel has competitive odds on the NFL Rookie of the Year and other NFL futures bets. This sportsbook also runs a highly rated betting app with attractive promotions for existing users and a substantial welcome bonus for new players.
• BetMGM Sportsbook: BetMGM offers competitive odds for all bet types, including NFL props and futures like the NFL Rookie of the Year. It also has a nice variety of ways to fund your account for convenient betting. Quality customer service and a generous welcome bonus await new customers. 
• Caesars Sportsbook: Caesars sometimes offers more favorable NFL betting odds on Rookie of the Year and other NFL futures than its competition does. Like the other sportsbooks, Caesars rolls out a competitive welcome bonus for new players. 

See here for a list of new betting sites as they launch in legal betting sites.

How to bet on NFL Rookie of the Year

To make an NFL Rookie of the Year bet you’ll need to register for an account at a legal online sportsbook. 

The process is simple, free, and fast. You can sign up at as many sportsbooks as you like. Start by following a link above to the sportsbook of your choice, which will qualify you for the best sportsbook bonus available today. 

Signing up is very straightforward. Once you visit the sportsbook of your choice, you will find a register or sign-up button at the top of the homepage. Click it and you’ll be taken to a sign-up form.

Here, provide information such as your name, address, email, and Social Security number. Once you’ve completed that step, you’ll be required to accept the sportsbook’s terms and conditions. 

If you are going to use a bonus code, which is available on our site if needed, you can enter it during the registration process. Before accepting a bonus offer for first-time account holders, we urge you to read the requirements. 

At this point, you’ll need to deposit funds to place a bet, which you’ll be able to do with a variety of secure banking options at legal sportsbooks. 

You’ll find the NFL Rookie of the Year betting options under the NFL tab and with the other NFL futures bets. Select your bet, decide how much you want to wager, and confirm your bets. After that, you’re all set. 

Remember to place bets only with legal online sportsbooks in your state. Offshore sportsbooks widely advertise their services, but they are illegal and provide you with no protection against fraud or other criminal activity. 

When is the best time to bet on NFL ROTY odds?

Successfully betting on the NFL Rookie of the Year requires monitoring player performance, statistics, news, and more. When it comes to an optimal betting time, that comes down to your own risk vs. reward preferences. 

After all, the NFL Rookie of the Year can be bet on nearly year-round, and the earlier you choose to bet, the better the odds will be. Of course, you’ll know more if you wait. Let’s break down some pros and cons. 

Pros and cons of betting early on the NFL Rookie of the Year: The pros to betting early include having an opportunity to find better value. The odds are new and haven’t been adjusted due to player news, performance, or other factors. Cons include the limited information to make a bet and the higher risk of a player falling out of contention for the award.

Pros and cons of waiting to bet on the NFL Rookie of the Year: The biggest pro to waiting is all the stats, news, and player performance data that can inform your decision once the season is underway. You’ll have a much better idea of which players are beginning to stand out.

The cons include a reduced opportunity to find value in the futures market, as well as odds that are not as favorable as they once were. 

Always consider your risk tolerance before deciding when to place your bets. Gather as much information as possible and monitor your chosen players before you bet your hard-earned cash.  

Offensive ROTY and Defensive ROTY

There are two awards given annually to the top first-year players in the NFL: Offensive Rookie of the Year and Defensive Rookie of the Year. 

On the offensive side of things, the award typically goes to a quarterback or other skill player. On the defensive side, pass rushers, linebackers, and defensive backs all compete for the honor. 

Winners stand out among their peers, as evaluated by stats, performance, and team impact. Some of the stats to track when betting the ROTY include: 

Defense

• Tackles
• Sacks
• Tackles for loss
• Quarterback hurries
• Passes defended
• Interceptions

Offense

• Passing completions and attempts
• Touchdown-to-interception ratios
• Rushing attempts and yards
• Receptions and yards

Who are the past ROTY winners? 

The NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year award is given annually to the top first-year offensive player. Between 2010 and 2022, players from various positions and teams have taken home the trophy, showcasing the league's rising talent. These players have included quarterbacks, running backs, and wide receivers.

Similarly, the NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year award is for the best first-year defensive player. Defensive tackles, linebackers, and cornerbacks have all recently claimed the honor.

Below are the winners since 2010 for each of the awards: 

Offense

Defense 

What other NFL awards can I bet on? 

The National Football League gives out several prominent awards at the end of each season, and you can bet on the vast majority of them via NFL futures odds.

Below are the awards most commonly bet on at online sportsbooks: 

• NFL MVP odds
• NFL Offensive Player of the Year
• NFL Defensive Player of the Year
• NFL Comeback Player of the Year
• NFL Coach of the Year

Other popular NFL futures bets you can make include: 

• Odds to win the Super Bowl
• Division champions
• NFL win totals